Headwater Study
It's finally here! There is a new version of the headwater guideline and it is ready for your comments. We have made great improvements to the document, including:
1. Overhaul of the evaluation section to include connections to the new headwater sampling protocol, which is now a new module in the Ontario Stream Assessment Protocol (OSAP).
2. The evaluation section has also been modified to allow sampling to be scoped based on important criteria, such as feature sensitivity, flow and form, and proposed alteration.
3. The classification system now takes the data that were collected through the evaluation and classifies features according to hydrology, riparian condition, and if negative alterations are proposed, fish and fish habitat, and terrestrial habitat. All factors are classified using the same categories: important, valued, contributing and limited functions.
4. We have added a flow chart that helps to link the classification to the recommended management.
5. The management section now provides very specific direction on when a management recommendation applies. There is also some direction provided to possible restoration options.
There is a 30-day commenting period, so please click here to provide your comments before May 10!

Since 2006, TRCA and partners have been undertaking a series of studies to better understand the natural functions of headwater drainage features. Headwater drainage features are small, temporary streams, swales and wetlands. These studies were undertaken by the study team because agencies and scientists are beginning to recognize that the natural functions associated with headwater drainage features are poorly understood and underestimated. While the functions of perennial headwater streams are fairly well accepted, temporary systems that may flow for only parts of the year are virtually unstudied and unmonitored. Their small size and the fact that they do not necessarily flow year-round, makes them particularly vulnerable to impacts such as piping, channelization, flow diversion, grade lowering and realignment. However, there is a growing body of evidence to suggest that headwater drainage features are important sources of food, sediment, nutrients, and flow to downstream aquatic systems, and they also provide water quality, storage and attenuation functions as well.
Improving our understanding of these systems is critical, and the timing for developing land use policies and guidelines for protecting headwater functions is now. The Greater Toronto Area and surrounding municipalities are expected to grow by 2 million additional people over the next 20 to 25 years. Much of this growth could be concentrated towards the upper reaches of our watersheds where the concentration of headwater drainage features is higher. This growth has the potential to have substantial impacts on our watersheds, hence it is essential that we understand the functions of headwater drainage features such that we can properly protect these important functions.
The following reports, guidelines and presentations are the up-to-date results of TRCA's Headwater Study.
Literature Reviews
Literature Reviews
- The Natural Functions of Headwater Drainage Features: A Literature Review, March 2007 - 1,712K

- A Review of the Enclosure of Watercourses in Agricultural Landscapes and River Headwater Functions - 1,367K

- The Economic Importance of Agricultural Drainage with Emphasis on the Enclosure of Open Drains in Ontario - 1,105K

- Enclosing Surface Drains: What's the Story? - 357K

Reports to Funders
Reports to Funders
- Report to Oak Ridges Moraine Foundation
- Report to Lake Simcoe Clean Up Fund
Headwater Monitoring Protocol
Presentations
Presentations
- Ministry of Natural Resources Lunch and Learn - 6,520KB

July 2011, Peterborough - Eastern Ontario Headwater Workshop
February 2011, Ottawa - Workshop Presentations Preserving Ontario's Headwaters
March 2010, Black Creek Pioneer Village - Headwater Workshop Summary and Presentations
May 2009, Black Creek Pioneer Village
Research Results
Research
- Headwater Research: "A preliminary investigation into the ecological significance of headwater drainage features in Southern Ontario" by Odum Idika, Masters Thesis, University of Waterloo
Full Thesis - 1,611K
Abstract - "Understanding the factors that influence headwater stream flow in response to storm events" by Les Stanfield and Don Jackson - 796K

- Seasonal Fish Habitat Study:
Draft Sampling Headwater Drainage Features to Test Field Methods and to Assess Seasonal Fish Habitat, March 2010 - 6,180K
- "Effects of anthropogenic alterations to ephemeral and intermittent headwater drainage features on downstream fish communities" by Julie Hennigar, Masters thesis, University of Waterloo - 2,292K

Current Projects
Current Projects
In January 2013, a two-day workshop was held in Ottawa to bring together experts in an effort to develop a study design for addressing the question of how many headwater tributaries can be removed before watershed impacts result. This workshop was called "Trimming the Tribs" and was a great success! The participants shared ideas and developed a scientific approach to answering this question; the notes from this workshop are below. Following the workshop, a number of the participants, including academics from the University of British Columbia and University of Ottawa, as well as TRCA and MNR, submitted an NSERC proposal to fund a number of PhD students who would apply the approach that was developed at the workshop and carry out the scientific study. Stay tuned!
Partners
Partners
Region of Peel
Oak Ridges Moraine Foundation
Lake Simcoe Clean Up Fund
Great Lakes Sustainability Fund
Fisheries and Oceans Canada
Region of York
Ministry of Natural Resources
Conservation Halton
Credit Valley Conservation
Remedial Action Plan
Lake Simcoe and Region Conservation Authority
University of Waterloo
Ausable Bayfield Conservation Authority
Upper Thames River Conservation Authority
Southern Ontario Stream Monitoring and Research Team
Parish Geomorphic
Abstract:
Headwater Research: A preliminary investigation into the ecological significance of headwater drainage features in Southern Ontario"
by Odum Idika, Masters Thesis, University of Waterloo
Abstract: Within Southern Ontario urban development is rapidly devouring headwater systems, and this can have significant repercussions to the health of entire river networks. The ecological contributions of headwaters to downstream aquatic systems are poorly understood. The relationships between exported organic material (invertebrates, organic detritus) and land use were examined from 16 headwater systems (13 ephemeral channels, 3 intermittent channels) located in and around the Toronto Region. Drift traps, precipitation and crest stage gauges were installed at each location to capture exported materials, measure rainfall and estimate peak flow, respectively. Samples were collected during runoff events, snow melt or precipitation from March through November 2008. The amount of snow melt or precipitation necessary to trigger surface runoff was found to be highly dependent on land use and antecedent conditions. Invertebrates of aquatic and terrestrial origin were collected, with aquatic animals comprising 43% and 87% of the total from ephemeral and intermittent headwaters, respectively. The mean export of organic materials was 963 invertebrates event-1 (0.65 g) and 32.0 g of plant matter event-1. The amount of materials transported was highly variable among samples (1 - 13,751 invertebrates event-1).
Within ephemeral channels, Annelida, Insecta and Chironomidae were the most numerous aquatic taxa (representing 40%, 24% and 23% of the total number of invertebrates transported event-1, respectively), while Mollusca, Arachnida and Insecta were the most numerous terrestrial taxa (representing 35%, 21% and 16% of the total number of invertebrates transported event-1, respectively). Earthworms contributed 64% of the total invertebrate volume collected event-1. Chironomidae, Crustacea and Trichoptera were the most numerous aquatic taxa collected from intermittent channels (representing 55%, 27% and 8% of the total number of invertebrates transported event-1, respectively), whereas Arachnida, Insecta, and Collembola were the most numerous terrestrial taxa (representing 52%, 19% and 13% of the total number of invertebrates transported event-1, respectively). Trichoptera accounted for 59% of the total aquatic invertebrate volume collected event-1.
Preliminary results suggest that the ecological contributions of headwaters to downstream systems are considerable and their importance should not be overlooked.
Headwater Workshop Summary and Presentations:
Headwater Workshop Summary and Presentations
May 2009, Black Creek Pioneer Village
Workshop Program - 34K ![]()
Break Session Summary - 40K ![]()
Theory and Science of Headwater Streams:
Headwater Drainage Feature Assessment Guidelines - 477K ![]()
Gap Analysis and Advancing the Science - 1,995K ![]()
Quantifying the Factors that Influence Flows in Headwater Streams - 3,586K ![]()
Quantification of Processes within a Headwater Channel Network - 2,889K ![]()
Invertebrate Drift from Headwater Drainage Channels in the Greater Toronto Area - 186K ![]()
Current Approaches to Headwater Monitoring: Check Your Watershed Day - 4,411K ![]()
Geomatics Tools for Mapping Headwater Streams - 5,831K ![]()
DFO's Application of the Fisheries Act (and Species at Risk Act) to Headwater Areas - 608K ![]()
Provincial Policy/Legislative tools for Protecting Headwater Functions - 2,799K ![]()
Conservation Authorities Act - 861K ![]()
Headwater Drainage Features: Interim Headwater Guidelines - 1,845K ![]()
Workshop Presentations:
Workshop Presentations: Preserving Ontario's Headwaters
March 2010, Black Creek Pioneer Village
Agenda - 410K ![]()
Preserving Ontario's Headwaters, Andrew McCammon, Ontario Headwaters Institute - 1,071K ![]()
Report to Oak Ridges Moraine Foundation:
Report to Oak Ridges Moraine Foundation
Appendix II:
Draft OSAP Modules - 1,320K ![]()
Report to Lake Simcoe Clean Up Fund:
Report to Lake Simcoe Clean Up Fund
Identifying Linkages between Headwater Drainage Feature Condition and Nutrient Transport, March 2011 - 5,218K ![]()
Comments
We have updated the Headwater Guideline, and we want to hear from you!

